17 Amazing Treats Made with Peanut Butter Cups
These delicious desserts transform ordinary peanut butter cups into extraordinary treats. From frozen delights to warm baked goods, each recipe showcases the perfect chocolate-peanut butter combination.
Whether you’re using leftover Halloween candy or store-bought favorites, these creative recipes will satisfy any sweet tooth craving.
01. Frozen Ice Cream Sandwich Dessert
This layered dessert uses ice cream sandwiches, chocolate pudding, whipped topping, and chopped peanut butter cups. Hot fudge and caramel create rich flavor layers throughout.
The method involves stacking ingredients in a pan and freezing until firm. Each layer adds texture and sweetness to this impressive dessert.
This version works great for parties since it serves many people. You can make it ahead and keep frozen until ready to serve.
02. Chocolate-Dipped Cookie Sandwiches
This treat sandwiches peanut butter cups between Oreo cookie halves, then dips everything in melted chocolate. Coconut oil helps the chocolate coating stay smooth.
The dipping technique creates a rich outer shell that holds everything together. The contrast between crunchy cookies and creamy centers tastes amazing.
These bite-sized treats take some time but create impressive results. Perfect for special occasions or gift-giving to chocolate lovers.
03. Chocolate Bacon Peanut Butter Cookies
These soft cookies combine cocoa powder, chopped peanut butter cups, and crispy bacon pieces. The salty-sweet combination creates an unforgettable flavor experience.
The bacon adds a smoky crunch that balances the rich chocolate and peanut butter. This unexpected ingredient makes these cookies stand out from regular versions.
This method works best with thick-cut bacon cooked until very crispy. The extra prep time creates cookies that will surprise and delight everyone.
04. Ultimate Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies
This recipe creates part peanut butter cookie, part chocolate chip cookie with added peanut butter cup pieces. The dough combines the best of both cookie worlds.
The technique involves mixing both cookie doughs together with chopped candy pieces. This creates varied textures and flavors in every single bite.
These cookies bake quickly and please everyone at gatherings. You get three favorite flavors combined into one amazing treat.
05. Homemade Peanut Butter Cup Bars
These bars recreate the classic candy flavor in a larger format using peanut butter, chocolate, and graham crackers. The recipe gets consistently high ratings for taste and simplicity.
The method layers peanut butter mixture with melted chocolate in a pan. This creates the same flavor profile as store-bought cups but much bigger.
This version disappears quickly at parties and potlucks. Much easier than making individual candies but with the same delicious results.
06. Sweet Cookie Pizza with Peanut Butter Cups
This dessert pizza uses sugar cookie dough as the crust, peanut butter as the sauce, and chopped candy as toppings. The presentation looks just like real pizza.
The technique involves baking a large cookie base then spreading creamy peanut butter on top. Candy pieces get sprinkled over everything like pizza toppings.
This method creates a fun dessert that kids and adults love. Perfect for birthday parties or casual family gatherings.
07. Cupcake Pan Peanut Butter Brownies
These brownies use boxed mix baked in cupcake pans with whole peanut butter cups pressed into centers. The individual portions look adorable and taste incredible.
The cupcake pan method creates perfect single servings with built-in portion control. Each brownie has a melted candy center that stays gooey.
This version takes regular brownies to the next level with minimal extra effort. Great for bake sales or lunch box treats.
08. Molten Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
This rich cake combines chocolate and peanut butter with a gooey center that flows when cut. A chocolate glaze on top makes the presentation absolutely stunning.
The technique creates a molten center that stays warm and flowing. The contrast between firm cake and liquid center creates an amazing texture experience.
This dessert works best served immediately with vanilla ice cream. Perfect for impressing dinner guests or celebrating special occasions.
09. No-Bake Peanut Butter Cup Pie
This creamy pie uses graham cracker crust filled with cream cheese, peanut butter, and whipped topping. Chopped candy pieces garnish the top beautifully.
The no-bake method means you can make this ahead and chill until serving. The filling sets up firm but stays creamy and rich.
This version works great for summer when you want dessert without heating the kitchen. Ready to serve after just a few hours of chilling.
10. Churned Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream
This homemade ice cream starts with peanut butter base and gets churned with chopped candy pieces. The result tastes better than any store-bought version.
The churning method distributes candy pieces evenly throughout the creamy base. Fresh ingredients create much richer flavor than commercial ice cream.
This recipe requires an ice cream maker but creates professional results. Worth the extra equipment for this incredibly delicious frozen treat.
11. Frozen Peanut Butter Cookie Pie
This pie features chocolate cookie crust filled with smooth peanut butter mixture and topped with candy, whipped cream, and syrups. Best served frozen straight from the freezer.
The freezing method creates a firm texture that slices cleanly but melts creamy on your tongue. Multiple toppings add different flavors and textures.
This version takes more assembly time but creates restaurant-quality results. Perfect for special celebrations or when you want something truly impressive.
12. Loaded Halloween Candy Brownies
These brownies get loaded with leftover Halloween candy including peanut butter cups, chocolate bars, and other favorites. Any candy combination works perfectly.
The method involves pressing chopped candy into brownie batter before baking. This creates pockets of different flavors and textures throughout.
This version helps use up excess Halloween candy in a delicious way. Great for cleaning out the candy bowl after trick-or-treating.
13. Quick Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake
This simple shake blends chocolate ice cream, milk, and crumbled peanut butter cups into a thick, creamy drink. Ready in just five minutes with amazing results.
The blending technique breaks up candy pieces while keeping some chunks for texture. The consistency stays thick enough to eat with a spoon.
This method works great for quick desserts or afternoon treats. Perfect for hot summer days when you want something cold and sweet.
14. Classic Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
These reliable cookies press whole peanut butter cups into warm cookie dough centers. Freezing the candy beforehand prevents melting during assembly.
The technique involves baking cookies partway, then pressing in frozen candy and finishing baking. This keeps the cups from completely melting away.
This foolproof method works every time when you follow directions exactly. Great for beginning bakers who want guaranteed delicious results.
15. Premium Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream
This rich ice cream rivals professional ice cream shops with its creamy texture and generous candy pieces. The homemade base tastes much better than store versions.
The technique creates extra smooth texture by properly tempering ingredients and churning at correct speed. Quality ingredients make a huge difference in final results.
This version requires an ice cream maker but produces superior results. Worth the investment for anyone who loves premium frozen desserts.
16. Swirled Brownie Bars with Peanut Butter
These brownies start with boxed mix but add swirled peanut butter mixture and chopped candy pieces. The swirling creates beautiful marbled patterns throughout.
The swirling technique involves dropping peanut butter mixture on brownie batter and dragging a knife through both. This creates attractive marbled appearance.
This method saves prep time while creating bakery-quality results. Perfect when you want impressive brownies without making everything from scratch.
17. Triple Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies
These loaded cookies contain chocolate chips, peanut butter chips, and chopped peanut butter cups in every bite. Three different chocolate elements create incredible flavor depth.
The technique distributes all three mix-ins evenly throughout the dough. This ensures every cookie has the perfect balance of chocolate and peanut butter.
These cookies please everyone and disappear quickly at gatherings. The combination of textures and flavors makes them absolutely irresistible to chocolate lovers.
Final Thoughts
These creative recipes prove that peanut butter cups work beautifully in countless desserts. From quick five-minute shakes to elaborate frozen pies, there’s something for every skill level and occasion.
Whether you’re using leftover Halloween candy or treating yourself to fresh ingredients, these recipes will satisfy any chocolate-peanut butter craving perfectly.